Bracketology

FINAL Bracketology 2020

Bracket Summary

After 11 days of reflection and no basketball, I finally decided to clean up a final bracketology post for the 2020 season. The season itself had so many great stories happen, from Dayton to San Diego State to Baylor to East Tennessee State, we are left to sit and wonder how this whole thing would have played out. Perhaps in future decades, we will look back on this season with a clearer perspective and more appreciation. In any event, it is time to take a look at the best possible guess on what Selection Sunday may or would have looked like.

First, some updates

  • Last week, Kansas HC Bill Self revealed that Kansas would have selected to be in the Houston Regional instead of the heavily forecasted Indianapolis Regional. As the projected overall #1 seed, Kansas would have had that luxury. And it makes some logical sense. Many of the teams in Big 10 country, places like Kentucky and Louisville, and even teams like Butler would also prefer to play in Indianapolis. The thinking here from Kansas was, why compete for tickets in Indianapolis against other large fan bases, when we can remain near the Big 12 footprint in Houston and have a lot less competition for ticket share. Thusly, Houston made more sense, percentage-wise, for KU to gain the largest possible home court advantage. This final bracket projection now reflects this choice.

  • The domino effect from the Kansas decision starts on the 3-seed line. Kentucky was able to conveniently move over to the Indianapolis Region (Baylor is the top seed) and maintain competitive balance within the top 16 teams on the overall seed list, a bracketing requirement. That then meant shifts were required for all of the remaining 3-seeds. Duke shifted to the East, Michigan State shifted to the South, and the final 3-seed Seton Hall was placed in the West.

  • The next major shift requirement came with BYU. BYU could no longer be part of the same sub-region as Kansas. With those games now in Houston slated for Friday/Sunday, that means BYU will not be able to participate there. BYU is required to play in a Thursday/Saturday regional. The Cougars were ultimately moved to the Indianapilis-based Midwest Region. This caused the other 5-seeds to reshuffle as well with the exception of Ohio State, who remained in the West.

  • Lines 6-10 had a few additional tweaks. The most noteworthy was Colorado’s loss in the Pac-12 Tournament’s opening round. This caused a drop on the seed list for the Buffaloes, and landed them on the 8-seed line. This allowed Saint Mary’s to move up to a 7-seed.

  • For the Bubble, Xavier’s loss to DePaul was just enough to knock the Muskateers out of the field entirely. I personally sympothize for any team that had to take the court on that final day (Wednesday, March 11). The news came in rapidly throughout that Wednesday. Several announcements of tournaments moving to no fans and more. By the end of the evening, we knew the NBA had suspended play. Yet, College Basketball carried on late into Wednesday night.

    Players and Coaches were tasked with having to play through the adversity. You could visibly see some motivational differences in these games versus what we always are accustomed to seeing during a hard-fought Championship Week. As badly as I want to disregard the results of that day, the fact is I cannot. The games were still played and sanctioned by the NCAA. The results have to be treated as part of the season for the purpose of this exercise. If for any reason the NCAA Tournament was later played after suspension, the committee would’ve a difficult time making this decision, but would have reached the same conclusion. No team was penalized more by playing on this day than Xavier, with their loss that night. It is mostly a moot point now, since the tournament did not happen.

  • Boston University won the Patriot League Tournament Championship Game on Colgate’s home court. That game was played with tremendous energy and had a ton of excitement. Especially considering that it happened on the evening of March 11th as well. Congratulations to the Terriers on winning the Patriot League Tournament trophy, something they will cherish forever.

  • The AAC Tournament never tipped off. And it left the final bracket in a position to accept Cincinnati as the auto-bid and afforded the AAC to recieve three bids. I believe that if the games did happen and either Houston or Wichita State won the AAC Tournament, the AAC would have concluded as a 2-bid league. Interesting how this season-long bracket forecasting saga for the AAC’s bid totals will never will be resolved.

Bracket projections are based on 2019-20 NCAA Committee Principles and Selection Process. Projected Conference Champions are based on projected Auto-Bid winners.

At-Large Bids Stolen: 1 (Cincinnati)

FIRST FOUR TEAMS OUT: Xavier, Texas, Northern Iowa, Stanford NEXT FOUR TEAMS OUT: Mississippi State, St. Louis, Memphis, Arkansas FOLLOW ME ON TWITTER: @roccomiller8

FIRST FOUR TEAMS OUT: Xavier, Texas, Northern Iowa, Stanford
NEXT FOUR TEAMS OUT: Mississippi State, St. Louis, Memphis, Arkansas
FOLLOW ME ON TWITTER: @roccomiller8

Bracketology 03.10.20

New Conference leaders since previous bracket. Represented below as Automatic Bids:
AAC - Cincinnati
Big East - Creighton
Big South - Winthrop (AUTO-bid secured)
Horizon - Northern Kentucky
MVC - Bradley (AUTO-bid secured)
MWC - Utah State (AUTO-bid secured)

Bracket projections are based on 2019-20 NCAA Committee Principles and Selection Process. Projected Conference Champions are based on projected Auto-Bid winners.

At-Large Bids Stolen: 1 (Cincinnati)

FIRST FOUR TEAMS OUT: NC State, Texas, Stanford, Northern Iowa NEXT FOUR TEAMS OUT: Mississippi State, St. Louis, Memphis, Arkansas  FOLLOW ME ON TWITTER: @roccomiller8

FIRST FOUR TEAMS OUT: NC State, Texas, Stanford, Northern Iowa
NEXT FOUR TEAMS OUT: Mississippi State, St. Louis, Memphis, Arkansas

FOLLOW ME ON TWITTER: @roccomiller8

Bracketology 03.06.20 - Bubble Trouble

Bracket Notes:

  • Tulsa is back today as a projected bid thief. The Golden Hurricane have sole possession of first place in the American after beating Temple and watching Houston lose last night.

  • If we want to pretend that no bid thieves happen this year, then Wichita State is the last team in. As discussed all season, the annual average is 2.4 bids taken away per year due to Championship Week surprises. That tells us that the final two teams in today’s projected field would also need help to get in - Richmond and N.C. State.

  • Ohio State now has captured the final 4-seed thanks to Auburn’s home loss against Texas A&M. The Buckeyes also helped themselves out with another win against a tournament-bound team last night, Illinois.

  • Rutgers plays at Purdue this weekend in the bubble game of all bubble games. The Rutgers road/neutral struggles are well documented, and this is the final chance for an away win against anyone in the Top 190. However, this game is a make or break even more for the Boilermakers. Purdue sits at 14 losses, a loss here will put them on path to 16 losses. However, a win here will almost guarantee them a bid. So much at stake for Purdue.

  • The bubble is crowded. You can make the case for Texas, NC State, and Richmond - which I have today. But you can also make a case for Wichita State, Utah State, and Stanford. We covered the Rutgers/Purdue saga above, so I expect only one of those two to make it. Additionally you have Cincinnati, Memphis, and Tennessee all right there looking to make a final push as well. Lastly, if we somehow ended up with four bids stolen, there would be no room for any of these teams listed. The drama is real.

  • We have a couple of new conference leaders this morning besides Tulsa. We welcome Eastern Washington and N.C. Central to the field.

New Conference leaders since previous bracket. Represented below as Automatic Bids:
AAC - Tulsa
Big Sky - Eastern Washington
Big Ten - Wisconsin
MEAC - North Carolina Central

Bracket projections are based on 2019-20 NCAA Committee Principles and Selection Process. Projected Conference Champions are based on projected Auto-Bid winners.

At-Large Bids Stolen: 1 (Tulsa)

FIRST FOUR TEAMS OUT: Wichita State, Utah State, Stanford, Purdue  NEXT FOUR TEAMS OUT: Cincinnati, Memphis, Tennessee, South Carolina  FOLLOW ME ON TWITTER: @roccomiller8

FIRST FOUR TEAMS OUT: Wichita State, Utah State, Stanford, Purdue
NEXT FOUR TEAMS OUT: Cincinnati, Memphis, Tennessee, South Carolina
FOLLOW ME ON TWITTER: @roccomiller8

Bracketology 03.02.20

Bracket Notes:

Another thrilling weekend of basketball is now behind us. Where did the season go? Seriously. In a few short days, we will have part one of Championship Week tipping off. It is always a bittersweet time of year. It doesn’t get better than the excitement of postseason College Basketball come March, but is also hard to say goodbye to hundreds of teams that we’ve been tracking since the offseason. It’s always hard to say goodbye to each team, but this is why we love college hoops!

We witnessed six of the top eleven teams lose over the weekend from Friday’s update. The aftermath from those results allowed Seton Hall to climb into the 2-seed position. The Pirates had another big road win, at Marquette to seize the opportunity.

Speaking of big road wins, Michigan State really took it to Maryland on their home floor on Saturday. The Spartans led virtually from wire-to-wire and put themselves in position to be a top four seed today.

The 5-seeds are completely full of Big Ten teams, thanks in part to Colorado losing twice last week to create some additional room. The Wisconsin Badgers have simply played their way into the fifth seed after winning at Michigan last week and adding a win over Minnesota yesterday. For this to actually work within the bracketing rules and procedures, a potential second round pairing of the lone Big Ten 4-seed Michigan State and Ohio State was done intentionally. The Buckeyes and Spartans only play once on the regular season schedule, so this is still an option for the committee in an extreme scenario. Having a single conference occupy an entire seed line, qualifies as an extreme scenario in my book.

Virginia is finally beginning to emerge from a pack of mid-seeded teams (8-10) after holding on to a quality home win over Duke. The Cavs are well above .500 in the top two and top three quadrants which begins to stand out more and more when compared to some of the more mediocre power conference resumes in their seed range.

Oklahoma has gone from not selected in a bracket exercise here just ten days ago, to feeling really safe. How? The Sooners have positioned themselves as the highest 10-seed after a crucial win in Morgantown over a struggling West Virginia program and a critical win over Texas Tech at the beginning of last week.

Northern Iowa clinched the outright Missouri Valley regular-season Championship on Saturday. Their victory came on the road at Drake and propelled the Panthers up to #37 in NET at printing time. UNI now rests as the final 10-seed. Arch Madness begins this weekend and will contain great drama as always!

The final at-large bids today were not easy to forecast. It came down primarily to selection history and lessons learned from past committees. As it stands today, history is not on Stanford or Rutgers side for a final bid selection. The Cardinal are stuck with a NCSOS of 215. They likely need to be at least a couple of places inside the bubble to warrant selection. For the Scarlet Knights, I cannot envision a selection happening after not getting a single Q1/Q2 away win to date. They have one more shot before the Big Ten Tournament. Rutgers remains out of the projected field for now.

Utah State, Richmond, and Cincinnati claimed the last three selections. Keep in mind, I did not project any bid steals today, so this scenario is pretty unrealistic come Selection Sunday. My overall intuition tells me that the Atlantic 10 and MWC deserve a second team, although there is no rule saying this has to happen. Each league has a top five team (SDSU and Dayton), but no guarantees for an additional team. The Spiders have a more lucrative win over Wisconsin (hot of late) to accompany their win at URI. Cincinnati has four wins within the bubble (all against AAC teams), so I’m cautiously going with the Bearcats for the final selection. Check out the entire Big Board to get a good snapshot of the selection picture. From UCLA (current 11-seed) all the way through Texas (6th team out), my expectation is most of this will play its way out. Bid steals and quality wins away from home will help assist on who the final deserving selections belong to.

New Conference leaders since previous bracket. Represented below as Automatic Bids:
AAC - Houston
Big Sky - Montana
MAC - Akron
NEC - Robert Morris

Bracket projections are based on 2019-20 NCAA Committee Principles and Selection Process. Projected Conference Champions are based on projected Auto-Bid winners.

At-Large Bids Stolen: 0 (Highly Unlikely)

FIRST FOUR TEAMS OUT: Stanford, Rutgers, Rhode Island, Mississippi State NEXT FOUR TEAMS OUT: Memphis, Texas, Purdue, Alabama FOLLOW ME ON TWITTER: @roccomiller8

FIRST FOUR TEAMS OUT: Stanford, Rutgers, Rhode Island, Mississippi State
NEXT FOUR TEAMS OUT: Memphis, Texas, Purdue, Alabama
FOLLOW ME ON TWITTER: @roccomiller8

Bracketology 02.28.20 - Welcome Bruins

Pre-Weekend Bracketology from Bracketeer.Org

We have seen quite a bit of mid-week movement. Much more than previous weeks. Duke took a loss to Wake Forest which required a major look under the hood. They are now a 3-seed.

Wisconsin made a healthy jump after securing a quality road victory at Michigan. There are five Big Ten teams eating up the eight 5-6 seeds today.

UCLA remained on fire last night thanks to a phenomenal game-winning three by Jaime Jaquez, to beat Arizona State in the Game of the Year in the Pac-12. UCLA has gone from a rebuilding season and surged all the way into today’s field. Plenty of work left to do for the Bruins, though. They have a risky NCSOS (217) and NET (76).

A notable omission this morning is the Rutgers Scarlet Knights. This was an excruciatingly tough decision because there is not a lot to compare to this resume historically. Rutgers is 1-10 in Away/Neutral games with only a win at Q3 Nebraska. Rutgers has five wins above the bubble, all at home. If nothing else changes, this will be the most controversial team discussed in the committee room.

Northern Iowa remained on the 12-seed line, but their resume is once again inside the bubble. Something important to keep in mind as we all buckle up for Arch Madness next weekend.

New Conference leaders since previous bracket. Represented below as Automatic Bids:
ACC - Florida State
Big Sky - Northern Colorado
MAC - Bowling Green
Pac-12 - Oregon (This changes almost every update!)
Summit - North Dakota State

Bracket projections are based on 2019-20 NCAA Committee Principles and Selection Process. Projected Conference Champions are based on projected Auto-Bid winners.

At-Large Bids Stolen: 0 (Highly Unlikely)

FIRST FOUR TEAMS OUT: Rutgers, Stanford, Richmond, Mississippi State NEXT FOUR TEAMS OUT: Memphis, Purdue, Arkansas, South Carolina FOLLOW ME ON TWITTER: @roccomiller8

FIRST FOUR TEAMS OUT: Rutgers, Stanford, Richmond, Mississippi State
NEXT FOUR TEAMS OUT: Memphis, Purdue, Arkansas, South Carolina
FOLLOW ME ON TWITTER: @roccomiller8